10 DIY Pet Toy Ideas You Can Make From Stuff You Already Have

Our pets love to play, indoors or out. But let’s be real—pet supplies can get pricey, and those grocery receipts and vet trips don’t lie. While we’d never cut corners on their basic needs, toys are a whole different story. Luckily, many fun and enriching pet toys can be made from stuff you already have at home. These DIY ideas will keep your pup and kitty active, engaged, and entertained without spending a dime!

DIY Toys for Your Pup

Dogs need toys that do more than look cute. Mental stimulation is what’s more important when they’re playing. The good news is you don’t need to hit the store to keep their tail wagging. From simple tug toys to mind-bending puzzle games, these homemade options are perfect for your pup.

Plastic Bottle Tug

Grab an empty plastic bottle (like a water or soda bottle) and remove the cap and label to avoid choking hazards. Slide the bottle into an old sock or a cut-off T-shirt sleeve and tie a knot at both ends to secure it. The bottle’s crunchiness creates a satisfying texture for your dog, and the fabric adds durability. This toy is perfect for light tug-of-war or solo chewing fun.

Muffin Tin Mystery

Take a muffin tin from your kitchen, place a few treats or pieces of kibble in several slots, and cover each one with a tennis ball, rolled-up socks, or plastic cups. Let your dog use their nose and paws to uncover the hidden rewards. It’s a simple yet engaging puzzle that adds mental stimulation to treat time.

T-Shirt Rope

Find an old cotton T-shirt, cut it into long strips, and tightly braid them together. Knot the ends securely to prevent unraveling. This homemade rope toy is great for tugging, chewing, and even a bit of fetch. Plus, repurposing an old shirt keeps waste out of landfills.

Busy Box

Grab a sturdy cardboard box (like an empty Amazon box) and fill it with crumpled paper, a few of your dog’s favorite small toys, and some hidden treats. Let your dog dig and search for the goodies. This DIY project taps into their natural foraging instincts and can be reused with new hiding spots.

Cloth Snuffle Mat

Cut an old fleece blanket, towel, or T-shirt into short strips. Thread and tie the strips through the holes of a rubber sink mat or sturdy dish rack. Bury kibble or small treats within the folds and let your dog sniff them out. This slows down fast eaters and provides mental stimulation.

DIY Toys for Your Kitty

Cats are natural hunters and need toys that tap into their instincts. They love chasing, pouncing, and batting at moving objects. To keep them entertained, you don’t need to buy fancy toys. With just a few household items, you can whip up some irresistible playthings in no time.

Embroidered Fish Chew Toy

Use scrap fabric (like old T-shirts or pillowcases) and cut out two fish shapes. Stitch around the edges, leaving a small opening, and fill it with cotton stuffing, catnip, or even dried herbs like mint. Close the opening and hand it over—this toy satisfies your cat’s biting, kicking, and chewing needs.

DIY Cat Wand

Take a sturdy stick or wooden spoon handle, tie a long shoelace, ribbon, or piece of yarn to the end, and attach a feather or strip of cloth to dangle. Wiggle the wand to mimic prey movements, encouraging your cat to leap and swat. It’s easy to make and turns playtime into an interactive bonding session.

Catnip Sock Toy

Grab an old sock, fill it with a handful of dried catnip (or even shredded paper if you’re out), and tie a knot to seal it. No sewing required. This toy invites your cat to pounce, bat, and wrestle, and it’s a cinch to remake when it wears out.

Yarn Pompon

Wrap yarn or string around your fingers (about 20–30 times), carefully slide it off, and tie it tightly in the middle. Cut the loops on both sides to create a fluffy pompon. These lightweight toys are great for tossing and batting, but always supervise to avoid unraveling.

Spider Toy

Use pipe cleaners (or twist ties from bread bags if that’s what you have) to form a simple spider shape with bent “legs.” The bouncy movement will spark your cat’s hunting instincts, and the DIY aspect makes it a fun and quick project.

Fun, Frugal, and Full of Love

With just a few everyday items and a bit of creativity, you can make toys that keep them happy and mentally stimulated. Not only are these DIY ideas budget-friendly and eco-conscious, but they’re also a great way to bond with your beloved pets while giving old household items a new purpose. So the next time their toy basket is looking a little bare, try one (or a few) of these simple and fun creations.